When in New York City, there are a number of vibrant scenes to be experienced – food, art, fashion, theater – but for those who take where they stay as seriously as what they do when they travel, the city’s flourishing boutique hotel scene is as unmissable as any. If you’re seeking an intimate, upscale property that’s an experience in its own right, booking a few nights in a boutique hotel on this list might be for you.
For context, boutique hotels were practically invented here. Typically built with 120 rooms or fewer, and characterized by strong, focused design identities, boutique hotels sprung up in the 1980s. The phenom is widely credited to Studio 64’s Ian Schrager, whose vibe-y, since-closed Morgans Hotel in Midtown is unofficially considered the world’s first boutique hotel. New on the scene this year are The Fifth Avenue Hotel and Warren Street Hotel, both featured on Condé Nast Traveler’s 2024 Hot List.
Read on for our edit of the best boutique hotels in New York City for out-of-towners and staycationers alike. If you know what general area you want to stay in, jump straight there below.
What is the best area to stay in New York City?
Midtown and downtown are the most popular and convenient areas for travelers bopping around Manhattan. Midtown is best for first-time visitors because of its central location and proximity to tourist attractions like Times Square, Broadway, the Empire State Building, The Met, Grand Central, and Central Park, while downtown is great for nightlife, top restaurants, and a more local experience. Brooklyn is a good choice for visitors who have seen the Manhattan highlights and are looking to explore neighborhoods with cool restaurants, bars, and shopping.
What makes boutique hotels special?
Boutique hotels are beloved for their strong character, intimate scale, and general cool factor. Their food and beverage programs are often a special focus, too, and can be destinations in and of themselves.
What are some pet-friendly boutique hotels in New York City?
Among the hotels on this list, almost all are pet-friendly, with varying weight limits allowed. Some do require a pet fee; The High Line Hotel, The Whitby, The Bowery, Warren Street Hotel, The Beekman, Crosby Street Hotel, Greenwich Hotel, One Hotel Brooklyn Bridge, Penny Williamsburg, and The William Vale, however, are fee-free. The Rockaway Hotel and Soho House do not allow pets, except for service animals at the latter.
